A firewall audit report documents what was reviewed, what was found and what should be fixed after a firewall audit. A useful report does more than list rule numbers. It explains the scope and method, rates each finding by risk, gives evidence and a specific fix, and summarizes the overall security posture in language leadership can act on. It also becomes compliance evidence for standards such as PCI DSS and ISO 27001.
This guide sets out what a firewall audit report should include, what weak reports leave out and how to use the report once you have it. For the audit process itself, see our step-by-step firewall security audit guide and our article on firewall rule audits.
What a Firewall Audit Report Should Include
1. Executive Summary
One page for non-technical readers: overall risk rating, number of findings by severity, the three to five most important issues, and the key recommendations. It should answer “how exposed are we and what do we need to do first?”
2. Scope and Objectives
- Firewalls, cloud security groups and network segments reviewed, with device names and versions
- Audit objectives, for example compliance with PCI DSS, alignment with internal policy or pre-migration cleanup
- What was excluded and why
- Audit period and date of configuration snapshots
3. Methodology
Explain how the review was performed: configuration exports analyzed, tools used, manual review steps, interviews held and standards referenced, such as NIST SP 800-41 Rev. 1, CIS Benchmarks or vendor hardening guides. A clear method lets readers judge how much assurance the report provides.
4. Rule Base Analysis
- Total rules and objects reviewed
- Overly permissive rules using “any” in source, destination or service
- Unused rules based on hit counts over a stated period
- Shadowed, redundant and duplicate rules
- Rules allowing risky services such as Telnet, FTP, SMB or RDP across trust boundaries
- Rules with no owner, justification or change reference
5. Configuration and Hardening Review
- Firmware and software versions, and known vulnerabilities affecting them
- Management access restrictions, MFA and administrator accounts
- Logging configuration and log forwarding
- Backup of configurations and high-availability settings
- Services enabled on the firewall itself
6. Architecture and Segmentation Observations
Comments on zone design, segmentation between environments (production, development, corporate, payment), remote access paths and exposure of management interfaces.
7. Detailed Findings
Each finding should follow the same structure:
| Field | What it contains |
|---|---|
| ID and title | Unique reference and short description |
| Severity | Critical, high, medium or low with the rating criteria stated |
| Affected devices and rules | Exact firewall, rule ID and objects |
| Description | What is wrong and why it matters |
| Evidence | Configuration extract, hit counts or screenshots |
| Business impact | What an attacker or failure could cause |
| Recommendation | Specific change, not generic advice |
| Owner and target date | Agreed during remediation planning |
8. Compliance Mapping
Where relevant, map findings to requirements. PCI DSS v4.0.1 Requirement 1 covers network security controls, including reviewing their configurations at least every six months. ISO 27001:2022 Annex A includes network security and segregation controls. Mapping helps compliance teams use the report as evidence.
9. Remediation Roadmap
Group fixes into immediate actions, short-term cleanup and longer-term improvements such as segmentation projects or a new change management process.
10. Appendices
Full rule analysis output, lists of unused and shadowed rules, tool reports and the sign-off record.
Signs of a Weak Firewall Audit Report
- Raw tool output with no validation or prioritization
- Generic recommendations such as “follow best practice” without rule-level detail
- No statement of scope, so readers cannot tell what was missed
- Severity ratings with no explained criteria
- No business impact, making it hard to justify remediation effort
- Findings that cannot be traced to specific devices and rules
How to Use the Report
- Brief leadership using the executive summary and roadmap, and agree on resourcing.
- Assign owners for each finding and add them to your ticketing system.
- Fix critical issues first through emergency change processes where necessary.
- Validate fixes with a targeted retest and update the report status.
- Share with auditors as evidence of periodic review, together with remediation records.
- Track trends across audits: total rules, permissive rules and unused rules should fall over time.
The same principles apply to security testing reports in general; our guide to the VAPT report explains how to read testing findings.
Key Takeaways
- A firewall audit report should cover scope, method, rule analysis, configuration, architecture, findings and a roadmap.
- Each finding needs evidence, severity criteria, business impact and a specific recommendation.
- Compliance mapping turns the report into audit evidence for standards such as PCI DSS.
- Use the report to drive owned remediation and track improvement over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a firewall audit report?
It is the document produced after a firewall audit that records the scope, method, findings, risk ratings and recommended remediation for the firewalls reviewed.
What should be in a firewall audit report?
An executive summary, scope, methodology, rule base analysis, configuration review, architecture observations, detailed findings with evidence, compliance mapping, a remediation roadmap and appendices.
Who should receive the firewall audit report?
Security and network teams use the detailed findings, leadership uses the executive summary and roadmap, and compliance teams and auditors use it as evidence of periodic review.
How often should a firewall audit report be produced?
Whenever a firewall audit is performed. PCI DSS requires network security control configurations to be reviewed at least every six months, and many organizations audit at least annually.
Is automated tool output enough for a firewall audit report?
No. Tool output is a useful input, but findings should be validated, prioritized by business risk and paired with specific recommendations.
Need a report your auditors and engineers can both use? Securis360’s firewall security review services deliver validated findings, compliance mapping and a clear remediation roadmap. Request a firewall audit.